Friday, 19 October 2012

A Question Of Loyalty

This story was first published in The Horizon Magazine in Zimbabwe, as I was very young when I wrote the story, I really can’t take all the credit. Forthwith, I acknowledge the help I got from Mr Peter Birkett, the British Airways Chief Security Officer who “taught me how to hijack planes.” Thanks also to Andrew Moyse, the Horizon Editor, for leaving out some of the laughable conversations I had included in the original script. Other than that, this is a story of my creation. The Zimbabwe Defence Forces also took a flirting interest in the story when it was published but it was all very cordial, very amicable. Read here therefore, the most beautiful story I have ever written. I closely followed the pattern of the master – Alistair Maclean – “no romance, it just slows down the action!”

This is the South African Airways Airbus A300 where the story narrated below may or may not have happened.


by Kudakwashe Kanhutu

The trip should have carried no drama at all. The flight to Johannesburg would be slightly under two hours and every time I had done the Jo’burg run, which is a relatively short hop and over land too, I was confident my safety was guaranteed, not that air safety was a major concern. As a high-ranking air force officer, I had seen so much combat action from military planes to the effect that civilian flight did not even stir my blood. I had no way of knowing that this particular trip would reshape my entire philosophy and forever change my laissez-faire attitude towards life.

As the big Airbus A300 aircraft swept off the runway into the night sky, my mind focused on the problems we were facing at home: nationwide workers’ strikes, university students’ demonstrations and a weak economy. It just wasn’t healthy. It was not my area of concern, but as I sized it up I conceded that disloyalty seemed to be taking over. Now, loyalty meant living to me. Those without loyalty left me cold and sad. I could not understand why one skilled at his work would do his country a disservice and go to serve abroad. University students and the workers’ strikes and the denunciation of government were cases of rebellion fit for animals, and wild animals at that. I believed everyone had a duty to the country, to the president and to God. I had taken the vow as a mere Red Cross youth member, as a Boy Scout, then again when I joined the air force and most recently when I took office within the defence forces. I therefore strongly felt everyone had to be loyal to the country and submit to government decisions and control. According to the bible, a leader of a country is installed by God and to despise his authority is blasphemy and a punishable sin.

But not for me. I was the one to stand up and be counted for my country. Fanatical loyalty was my daily bread, in my heart I believed that I was an integral part of government and therefore knew “government employee” would be my name until death. It was my view that the acute unemployment in the country existed only because school leavers were too choosy and afraid of hard work, so they stayed home and played havoc with the statistics. I had heard of innocent people wrongly sent to jail, but of course I had never heard of anyone who admitted to being guilty.

With that line of thought everything was cosy between the leadership of the country and me. I wished everybody would find solace in hard work and the spirit of aspiring to achieve a better status or go to jail to regain some manners relative to loyalty. The government always acted in the best interests of its citizens. Fantasy. I might as well have believed that the Devil took good care of his people.

Thirty minutes into the night flight I turned my attention to my fellow passengers. There were the two teenagers wearing hippy clothing and indecent haircuts. I grieved for the past. Further on, without having to strain my neck, there was the nervous couple in seats 23A and B. But it was behind them, in seats 24A, B and C, that my eyes rested. There was a mother and her two children – sweet twins aged about six. I gave them ten out of ten. A sense of peace and kindness descended upon me just watching the kids’ kitten like antics, 13 000 above planet Earth and they were so carefree.

I was about to turn to the newspaper the air hostess had handed me, when the pilot announced flatly that we had been hijacked by a lone gunman who was yet to make his demands known. Paralysis gripped me. First to go was the notion of air safety. How had the heavily armed gunman sneaked through airport security? A thousand years later, which I suppose was 15 minutes, the gunman made known his demands. He was a member of a commando unit and wanted two South African commandos, captured as cross – border saboteurs during the apartheid era, to be released and put onto a plane. These men were to be given weapons and flown by a civilian crew into South African air space and then para – dropped.

A time limit was given: in the 40 minutes we still had to touchdown in Johannesburg, a plane was to be refuelled and made to stand by. The South African authorities would make ‘phone call one’ – high priority phone call for exactly five minutes to the authorities of my country, where these commandos were being held. My country would then authorise the release of the prisoners, drive them to the airport and allow them to make sure there no security personnel masquerading as crew or hiding somewhere on board. After the airliner had taken off, the government of my country would only have lost two hours fuel and would have saved the 176 lives on board our aircraft. The operation was to take 40 minutes flat and anyone who slipped up on the deadline would be held responsible by the world for the 176 lives that would surely perish if the deadline was not met.

If the deadline was met, the lone gunman would receive a secret message, the first would come in 20 minutes to show that positive action was taking place and the second message after the plane had taken off with the prisoners on board. This meant there were many accomplices on the ground, who would phone Johannesburg’s control tower then get the passwords relayed to our aircraft. This was clearly a military operation. During my military service I had undergone anti – hijack training. I knew all about staying calm, assessing the situation, calculating the risk and taking appropriate action, but despite that my fear was all consuming and was reflected all around me by my fellow passengers. Returning to earth, out of control and at bullet-speed is never part of the bargain when we take to the sky. Also, the fact that the hijacker had not misdirected his energy running up and down aisles threatening every passenger in sight credited him as a highly trained and focused soldier, and identified him as a formidable foe.

But what really was there to my fear? My government knew that I and other passengers were on board. The terrorist’s demands would be met on the double and all 176 passengers would disembark at Jan Smuts Airport, shaken but with big smiles and a tale each for their folks. It was easy really, the two commandos, weak from the long stay in jail would bash their heads against rocks during the para – drop and foil their own escape.

I was deadly wrong. My trip was now a frightful flight with a big banner that said “governments do not make decisions under pressure from terrorists.” I could not believe it; my own government would actually make us go through such an ordeal just for the sake of a twisted political standpoint. It was said that terrorism should be discouraged in its infancy; if terrorists won a small victory they would insist on bigger things. Of course who ever said this was conveniently not on board the same plane as me. Looking across at the twins I was overwhelmed by helpless anger. They were worth a thousand terrorists’ political demands and yet my government had authorised “whatever measures might be necessary to free the hostages”!

Things were happening all at once, the gunman had instructed the pilot to dump almost all fuel as a negotiating tactic, our engines would clank shut any moment, and without thrust our aircraft was as impressive as a mouthful of dust. If our government intervened we would just make it to landing. I had lived my last and all my loyalty and confidence in government suddenly waned. I cursed the vulgarity of politics and with it our expendability; we were just pawns on a very big chessboard.

Promptly the gunman emerged in the aisle. He was a white man in his thirties and he wore a black combat outfit and his face was painted black. A handgun was stuck in his belt within easy reach and a sub – machine gun was slung casually over his shoulder, his ammunition belt was well supplied. However, he was not shooting. He had high explosive charges which he place randomly around the plane. One mistake and we would all be blown to smithereens. I visualized little pieces of metal and human flesh raining down on the slumbering city of Jo’burg. As he carried out his operation, his eyes were ever watchful and his reflexes fully alert. I knew a surprise attack would only end with the incapacitation of the perpetrator, and so to keep my mind off it I looked out of the window. I saw a fighter plane performing a steep climb with the blue blow – torch after burner flame trailing behind. Fancy dramatics I thought bitterly. When I looked back, the air pirate was standing, looking down at the twins. Their mother was clutching the twins desperately, protecting them from the menacing gaze. 

The gunman was a terrorist and would stop at nothing. I thought, he would now begin the killing and it seemed he had chosen the twins to be the first. God, how I wished I had stayed on the anti – hijack team. Now would have been my day. However, I still knew a thing or two, my hands were starting to grasp the metal head of my seat belt when the hijacker moved off, heading swiftly to the cockpit. I sat at ease.

Our descent was sharp but I hardly noticed. When we levelled off I could see the Jo’burg lights. Then the plane banked sharply and we began heading west, away from the airport, shortly after, all our lights were extinguished, even the anti – collision lights went off, at first I imagined the aircraft’s systems had gone down, but the steady hum of the engines told me we were still in circulation. I later learned that the commando had said he was a soldier and did not kill children. So the lights off procedure was to facilitate a parachute jump under the cover of darkness. After about a minute of total darkness the lights came back on again. The hijacker had spared our lives but had severed our communications equipment. His jump meant that we were lower than 3 300 metres but still nowhere closer to the airport.

The aircraft banked sharply again and the engines screamed as we regained altitude and increased speed. After a few minutes of climbing sharply the two powerful engines fell silent. But the pilot had anticipated that, for he levelled off the big metal bird. We were now gliding on our own momentum and still in danger of crashing. When we were again above Johannesburg, the plane nose-dived sharply but noiselessly and we had neither radio clearance for landing nor the ability to regain altitude. The aircraft wavered as if to nose dive to our deaths and with both hands on the armrests I resolved that if I came out of this alive, I would never be a government yes – man again and my loyalty would be based on reason. I despised ‘disloyal’ people because I had not yet climbed the hill they had climbed in life. But now I knew the state can be an unfeeling monster.

As if this revelation was the magic moment that accessed our landing, our big airbus appeared directly above Jan Smuts Airport like a ghost, a little lower and the airport building’s roof would have been shaved off by our fully extended landing gear. The pilot wing – tipped the runway and the airbus silently touched down but without thrust reversers, we hurtled on towards the end of the runway on a collision course with a fully laden Boeing 747 – 400 aircraft preparing to take off. The pilot locked on the brakes and with less than 20 metres to spare we shuddered to a halt. The two aircraft sat facing each other peacefully till our peace was shattered some minutes later by black – clad anti – hijack men who, violently blew off our doors and entered with smoke – screens and such fanfare. 

The last I saw of the anti – hijack men our pilot was screaming his head off at their commander for being dramatic for nothing and terrorising the passengers with the violence of their entry. I could have walked off with a big smile if the pilot was hollering at the president of my country. I knew then my loyalty was dead. To the end of my days I will never who is the worse, terrorists who threaten public lives, or politicians who sometimes have the power to avert disaster but sacrifice innocent lives just for the sake of a political stand point.


A copy of the original publication.

Being Very Strong. Zimbabwe: The New National Security Paradigm

As the 32nd Independence Anniversary celebrations come to a close, being the good nationalists that we are; let's now go behind closed doors, away from the media and international scrutiny to talk about our failures. I volunteer that the government and all nationalists have failed Air Zimbabwe. This is my formulation:

 Air Zimbabwe's Boeing 767 - 200 Extended Range. Registration Mark: Zulu - Whisky Papa Foxtrot. Call sign: UM. The aircraft named Chimanimani.

by Kudakwashe Kanhutu

In a world with nuclear weapons, I am dismayed by the prospective ignominy of being defeated by our detractors without their having to resort to these ultimate weapons, or any other weapons for that matter. The first place I see this happening is when security is breached in fields that ordinarily should have no relation to orthodox national security. Indeed, times have changed. National security, properly conceived, now goes way beyond what happens on the battlefield; for the field has become much wider. Thus I am mortified that fellow nationalists seem not to realise this. It is critical that all nationalists understand the new pillars that undergird security. For brevity’s sake, I will rely only on one example although I can talk about a lot of other fields where failures will impinge on national security.

For my purpose this will suffice; the very fact that Air Zimbabwe is not flying today is a dagger to the heart of Zimbabwe’s national security. Yet I do not see a reaction in the same league as if an armed attack was under way. There is no recognition in our ranks that the national airline is as much a part of our security set up as our newspapers, our radio stations and our armed forces. There is no realisation of the shift in national security thinking. Our detractors now talk of a system of systems when talking about national security, since a disruption in any seemingly unrelated part eats away and weakens the whole structure. Attacks on these fringe aspects may seem insignificant but overtime will prove the death knell of the system. Therefore, if it becomes urgently incumbent in every nationalist’s mind that the way of preserving national security has shifted considerably, these sorts of insidious damages can still be remedied.

To go directly to the heart of the matter; there is no reason why, in a country that has millionaires in her nationalist ranks, the national airline can fail to fly because of an outstanding workers’ wage bill of around $40 million. I am outright saying here: there is no reason why the millionaires who claim to want to see the nationalist project succeed, should not – of their own volition – put money on the table to solve the national airline’s minor debt problem. The only reason I can think of is that they have not looked at the big picture and properly understood what role the national airline has played all along. Besides providing employment, Air Zimbabwe landing in Western capitals has been a symbol of stubborn defiance. A falsification of any propaganda claim that Zimbabwe is a failed state. It has been a significant foil to the prescient observation by Napoleon that “four hostile newspapers are to be more feared than a thousand bayonets.” Air Zimbabwe, flying anywhere in the world in the face of innumerable hostile newspapers, was a statement to counter all their malicious allegations against Zimbabwe.

Any negative effects the airline kept at bay will now feed directly into the system. Unemployment feeds into insecurity. Perceptions of disorganisation feed into insecurity. Let any newspaper now make an outlandish claim that Zimbabweans are so backward that not a single person there is trainable to become a pilot; who is to dispute that. Let anyone suggest the need for a civilising mission as they claimed in the colonial era, what do we have as an affront to that? Any charge of mismanagement of affairs is no longer unsustainable without the airline as our highly visible counter-argument. Those who know what is at stake will understand what I mean when I say losing the airline is very much the equivalent of giving our detractors our newspapers, radio and TV station.


Having understood each other on this count, I am then insistent that an unequivocal demand should be made on our wealthy fellow nationalists to produce the money required to return the airline to the skies. The national airline is a strategic asset that should be as non-negotiable to the true nationalist as our armed forces are. I will also say something briefly about the missed opportunity that should not be missed again once the airline returns to the air. The concept of ‘strategic inflection points’ dictates that the airline industry is now a field of alliances, once the airline is operating again, the government must without delay negotiate partnerships with airlines from countries we have no bad blood with. The only stipulation should be that our aircraft retain the national colours and thus maintain the value the national airline has for national security.

National security in its new permutation allows a reckless enemy to attack our symbols of nationhood and cause as much damage as a conventional military attack did in the old days. A patient enemy can just attack these symbols and wait for a nation to collapse due to the weaknesses ensuring thus, this is the whole logic behind sanctions. If we are scrupulous and diligent, we can counter these attacks on the new pillars of national security. What I refuse to accept is that sanctions are to blame for a national airline being unable to fly for want of $40 million dollars in a country with millionaires in its nationalist ranks. This is recklessness on our part.

Wednesday, 17 October 2012

Thucydides. The Only Authority On International Relations.

"In fine, I have written my work, not as an essay which is to win the applause of the moment, but as a possession for all time" - Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War.

I took this picture at the waterfront on the Island of Aegina, in September 2012, when I was visiting all the places where the History says the battles of the Peloponnesian War took place. 

by Kudakwashe Kanhutu

Most scholars of International Relations think the Melian Dialogue the most instructive passage in The History of the Peloponnesian War. I beg to differ. The passage below by Thucydides is one of the most compelling and densest historical accounts I have ever read. For me, the most instructive point is how thin the veneer of civility truly is, as evinced in the breakdown of order during the plague. Here is what Thucydides said about the plague, with nothing left out;

"The original outbreak, it is said, was started in Ethiopia, the far side of Egypt: the plague then spread to Egypt and Libya, and over much of the King’s territory. It fell on the city of Athens suddenly. The first affected were the inhabitants of the Peiraeus, who went so as to allege that the Peloponnesians had poisoned the wells (at that time there were no fountains in the Peiraeus). Afterwards the plague reached the upper city too, and now the number of deaths greatly increased.

Others, doctors or laymen, can give their individual opinions of the likely origin of the plague, and of the factors which they think significant enough to have had the capacity to cause such a profound change. But I shall simply tell it as it happened, and describe the features of the disease which will give anyone who studies them some prior knowledge to enable recognition should it ever strike again. I myself caught the plague, and witnessed others suffering from it.

It so happened that this year was commonly agreed to have been particularly free from other forms of illness, though anyone with a previous condition invariably developed the plague. The other victims were in good health until, for no apparent cause, they were suddenly afflicted. The first symptoms were a high fever in the eyes and reddening and inflammation of the eyes; then internally the throat and tongue began to bleed and the breath had an unnaturally foul smell. There followed sneezing and hoarseness of voice, and shortly the affliction moved down to the chest accompanied by a violent cough. When it settled in the stomach the turmoil caused there led to the voiding of bile in every form for which the doctors have a name, all this with great pain. Most of them suffered from an empty retching which brought violent spasms: in some this followed as soon as the vomiting had abated, in others much later.

The surface of the body was not particularly hot to the touch or pallid, but reddish and livid, breaking out in small pustules and ulcers. But the sensation of burning heat inside the body was so strong that sufferers could not bear the pressure of even the lightest clothing or sheets, or anything other than going naked, and their greatest wish was to plunge into cold water. Many who had no one to look after them did in fact throw themselves into cisterns, overcome by an insatiable thirst: but as a rule the quantity of water drunk made no difference. A constant infliction was desperate restlessness and the inability to sleep. Throughout the height of the disease there was no wasting of the body, but a surprising physical resilience to all the suffering, so that there was still some strength in them when the majority died from the internal fever after six to eight days. If they survived this period most others died from the consequent weakness when the disease spread down to the bowels causing heavy ulceration and the onset of completely liquid diarrhoea.

The disease first settled in the head then progressed throughout the whole body from the top onwards. If any survived the worst effects, symptoms appeared when the disease took hold in their extremities. It attacked genitals, fingers, and toes, and many lived on with these parts lost: some too lost their sight. There were those who on recovery suffered immediate and total loss of memory, not knowing who they were and unable to recognize their friends.

Indeed the pathology of the disease defied explanation. Not only did it visit individuals with a violence beyond human endurance, but there was also this particular feature which put it in a different category from all other diseases with which we are familiar: although many bodies lay unburied, the birds and animals which prey on human flesh kept away from them, or, if they did eat, died of it. Evidence of this was the notable disappearance of carrion birds, nowhere to be seen in their usual or any other activity: the dogs, being domestic animals, allowed more immediate observation of this consequence.

This then, leaving aside the many variants in the way different individuals were affected, was the general character of the disease. Throughout this time there were no attacks of the usual illnesses: any that did occur ended in the plague.

Some died in neglect and others died despite constant care. Virtually no remedy was established as a single specific relief applicable in all cases: what was good for one was harmful to another. No particular constitution, strong or weak, proved sufficient in itself to resist, but the plague carried off all indiscriminately, and whatever their regime of care. The most dreadful aspects of the whole affliction were the despair into which people fell when they realized they had contracted the disease (they were immediately convinced that they had no hope, and so were much more inclined to surrender themselves without a fight), and the cross-infection of those who cared for others: they died like sheep, and this was the greatest cause of mortality. When people were afraid to visit one another, the victims died in isolation, and many households were wiped out through the lack of anyone to care for them. If they did visit the sick, they died, especially those who could claim some courage: these were people who out of a sense of duty disregarded their own safety and kept visiting their friends, even when ultimately the family members themselves were overwhelmed by the scale of the disaster and abandoned the succession of dirges for the dead. But the greatest pity for the dying and the distressed was shown by those who had had the disease and recovered. They had experience of what it was like and were now confident for themselves, as the plague did not attack the same person twice, or at least not fatally. These survivors congratulated by all, and in the immediate elation of recovery they entertained the fond hope that from now on they would not die of any other disease.

The suffering was made yet more acute by the influx from the country into the city, and the incomers suffered most of all. With no houses of their own, and forced to live in huts which at that time of year were stifling, they perished in chaotic conditions: the dead and the dying were piled on top of each other, and half-dead creatures staggered about the streets and round every fountain, craving for water. The sanctuaries in which they had encamped were full of corpses – people dying there were not moved: all sacred and secular constraints came to be ignored under the overwhelming impact of the disaster, which left men no recourse. All previously observed funeral customs were confounded, and burial was haphazard, any way that people could manage. Many were driven to shameful means of disposal for lack of friends to help them, so many of their friends already dead: they made use of other people’s funeral pyres, either putting their own dead on a pyre constructed by others and quickly setting light to it, or bringing a corpse to a pyre already lit, throwing it on top of the other body in the flames, and then running away.

In other respects too the plague was the beginning of the increased lawlessness in the city. People were less inhibited in the indulgence of pleasures previously concealed when they saw the rapid changes of fortune – the prosperous suddenly dead, and the once indigent now possessing their fortune. As a result they decided to look for satisfactions that were quick and pleasurable, reckoning that neither life nor wealth would last long. No one was prepared to persevere in what had once been thought the path of honour, as they could well be dead before that destination was reached. Immediate pleasure, and any means profitable to that end, became the new honour and the new value. No fear of god or human law was any constraint. Pious or impious made no difference in their view, when they could see all dying without distinction. As for offences against the law, no one expected to live long enough to be brought to justice and pay the penalty: they thought that a much heavier sentence had already been passed and was hanging over them, so they might as well have some enjoyment of life before it fell…" 

Notes:

Thucydides, The Peloponnesian War, Book 2, Lines 48 – 54, pp.96 – 99.

Thucydides. “The Peloponnesian War.” Translated by Martin Hammond. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009.

A Debt Of Honor, A Debt Of Gratitude

"The best time to plant a tree was twenty years ago, the second best time is now" - Chinese Proverb 

My Homeland. It is criminal neglect for any country in Southern Africa to fail to feed itself.

If a sufficient number of development minded, progressive (indigenous) people start development projects in their rural areas all over the country (coordination is not even necessary); the end result has to be, must be, palpable good for Zimbabwe. Let me also point you to the fact that it is not an oversight that I do not mention Western aid ANYMORE in my writings.

by Kudakwashe Kanhutu


I have always thought that there needs to be a thorough redrafting of the way people reach positions of political leadership in Zimbabwe. I have always thought that people should not assume positions of political authority until they have paid a debt of gratitude to society. Some people only go into politics because of vanity - to imprint their names in history books - and above all to amass wealth. Our next generation of politicians have to be different in that one aspect: one should not, cannot, no, must not run for political office until they have paid their debt to society. This debt is a debt of honour, and it is a debt of gratitude: the communities that fostered us were the happiest possible communities and we have to make an input towards their continuity. We have to use our talents to develop the communities we come from before we seek to represent them.

In this regard, I am buoyed by the fact that fate has gifted Zimbabwe a unique opportunity to realise her development potential. I am not alone in recognising that the political problems that led to our exodus from Zimbabwe must have a positive side. I will not dwell long on this, but the poor treatment we have received in our host countries has imbued us with the spirit to return and build a functional country so that we will never have to leave again. Most importantly, perhaps, most of us have managed to pursue university and college educations of our choice. Also, the contact and work experience (in a host of development fields) in different countries is a gift nothing but fate could have conjured up for us. If I am right, Zimbabwe is poised to be Southern Africa’s Switzerland in a few short years. What needs to be done is to harness the skills of returning individuals. The most important thing for me is that this should be done in an apolitical way. It should not be done under the banner of this or that political party. It just has to be the individual or individuals giving back to the community that gave them so much.

To give an example, my family followed my grandfather to a protected village in the Zambezi Valley, having moved from Chivhu. The place we moved to was a former ‘protected village,’ this was a cluster of huts closely resembling each other, housing innumerable families. On my first night there, since I was only five I wandered and got lost. To make it hilariously worse I only knew my grandfather's first name - John - so it was quite a mission to find my family. The family that found me waited until day break then took me to the Chief and I was reunited with my family, eventually. Indeed this sounds anecdotal but given the depravity of some communities in this world, this anecdote could have been a tragedy. Among many other things, this indicates my community was functional as we pulled together. My debt to this community is this: the children of the people that made my community so great should also live under the umbrella of safety and happiness that I found when my family joined this community.

Every single one of us  - except the most conceited - has a debt to pay to our communities. This MUST be paid in full before we can hope to be capable representatives. Of course, there have been changes as to what makes communities great - advances in technology, economics and knowledge have supplanted historical routes of acquiring basic needs. I will venture that it is not enough anymore to just help an old widow with the harvest. Sustainability of any project we undertake is the target.

In outline, my personal debt will not have been paid until I have built 3 libraries across Mzarabani District and supply them with books sufficient to start a civilisation. Until I have paid for sports field developments and supply all the schools with sports equipment such as footballs, volleyballs, netballs, standard goals, nets etc. IMPORTANTLY as lack of food security is the bane of our community, I want to construct an agricultural supplies depot where our rural farmers will get seeds, fertilisers, chemicals and farm equipment spares at token prices. At the same time my great wish is to also build grain silos here, the first in the area whose sole purpose will be to store grain that will be given back to the same rural families in drought years.

This project will be one whose success will not be evident for at least five years, which time I think is the minimum for anyone interested in uplifting their communities to make an impact. If a sufficient number of development minded, progressive (indigenous) people start development projects in their rural areas all over the country (coordination is not even necessary); the end result has to be, must be, palpable good for Zimbabwe. Let me also point you to the fact that it is not an oversight that I do not mention Western aid ANYMORE in my writings.

Fighting Fire With Fire

“In the midst of peace, war is looked on as an eventuality too distant to merit consideration” – Vegetius.

S - 400 All Altitude Missiles (Russian). Making the skies safe for locals. Picture by Open Source INTelligence.

by Kudakwashe Kanhutu 

[Balancing, since pleas to common sense are bound to fail...] 

The insights of the above Vegetius quote are not lost to the African National Congress Youth League. Thus, Julius Malema was right to opine that Botswana presents an insidious threat to stability in the SADC region if it allows foreign powers to have bases there. We all saw the stupidity of Laurent Gbagbo who tried to talk about sovereignty when French troops already had bases in Ivory Coast; the same troops who put Gbagbo in power then toppled him. The AU Charter should not allow member states to have foreign military bases on their territory,[1] but of course the AU Charter is a script for a stand-up comedy routine: Djibouti, Ivory Coast and Uganda, to name a few, already house AFRICOM structures of some sort. I also thought it unfortunate that President Zuma would come down on Julius Malema for saying “regime change,” a term that has never got anyone in trouble as it is a common term among leaders in the West, but I digress. If we agree that the AU Charter is: (1) a worthless rag and, (2) that the traditional notion of sovereignty anyway would conflict with any Charter article prohibiting inviting foreign forces – and thus allows any country to have military to military cooperation with any power to its heart’s content – then the way to counter threats posed by foreign forces in neighbouring countries is an imperfect but age old one. 

A First Sight of the Problem: 

When I was in Pretoria last year at a meeting with United States policymakers, one of the questions that was raised by them was how can the United States mend fences with the ANC? You see, the United States was the chief backer of South Africa’s apartheid system (much in the same way they back Israel today, common sense and world opinion be damned!). Hell, President Nelson Mandela was still listed as a terrorist in the United States as late as 28 June 2008. Yes – 28 June 2008. I opined four clear steps that could ameliorate the trust deficit that thus exists between the United States and African states. Among my steps was a plea for the U.S and her proxies to respect the AU/SADC position on African issues. Looking back, I now think that the U.S delegates’ question was a rhetorical question; my time would have been better spent had I chosen to speak to the many rocks that speck the South African landscape. Their further responses in the discussion betrayed what I have now come to immediately recognise as an entrenched attitude of listening politely then completely ignoring AU/SADC wishes. 

Well, if people show such disdain towards a magnanimous and forgiving people as the United States has done to SADC, some posture has to be taken. From the first day I understood the full history of colonialism and apartheid, I have always said it is the United States which should be begging to have a relationship with SADC and not the other way round. SADC did not wrong the US and her proxies; it was the U.S and her proxies that brought apartheid and colonialism to our shores and perpetuated it. Why then are the African states on all fours to be recognised by the former coloniser? It is a big question with many answers, such as; on the one hand you have idiocy and sycophancy in the same country (read Gbagbo and Quattara respectively), while on the other hand you have inexplicable stances such as that of Botswana under Ian Khama; name the man or woman who can explain Botswana’s counter productive agitation towards other SADC states. 

But the answer I think is significant as to why African states still court the former oppressor is that there is a sparseness of credible alternatives. To illustrate my point I will use Zimbabwe as my example from here on. We have all heard of Zimbabwe’s Look - East policy, much good has that done; China could not even inject the $10 bn that was needed to keep the Zimbabwean economy afloat in 2008. Also despite the exaggerated cries of a ‘yellow peril’ by the West, I too have misgivings about the conduct of Chinese investors towards Africans. Thus I argue a better variant. I argue that in China, we are courting the wrong giant, on the wrong field; for the next six years we should court President Putin’s Russia in all fields. China has its uses but it walks too softly. Russia on the other hand, has sharply pronounced an ambition to see the basic building blocks of international law preserved. It is Russia that has said that natural resources should remain an issue of national sovereignty where other greedy nations are planning an onslaught against this long standing principle of international law.[2] It is Russia which has been adamant that non intervention in a state’s domestic affairs should be upheld, otherwise all hell breaks loose. Russia too went through the catastrophic economic quandary, which the United States is so wary of; and survived without having to plunder foreign lands. Russia has never been a colonial power in Southern Africa or have they enslaved our people, or sponsored apartheid here in any form. Russia under President Putin is a good country to have relations with in all fields. Mind you, how else can we solve the Botswana problem? 

Every Problem Has A Solution: 

We all know from childhood the story where the hare challenged the elephant to a tug-of-war on the same day he challenged the hippopotamus. The hare’s plan was to pit these two giants against each other for his amusement, and he did. Without any culpability on our part, we find ourselves in a near similar situation today. The slight difference is that, it is the hippopotamus that has been challenging us (a minnow) to a tug-of-war for the past 12 years, while the elephant, gentle giant that he is, has been indifferent. I am not going to continue along the path of parables and fable-speak for long, for the point I am making is a practical point with real world consequences. Thus, let’s forthwith assign terms; Zimbabwe is the hare, The United States of America and its underlings, Britain, France and Germany represent the hippopotamus, while China or Russia (under President Putin) is our gentle giant; the elephant. We just may now have our window of opportunity to accept the hippopotamus’ long standing challenge to a tug-of-war, and like the hare in our fable; we must bring the elephant to this tug-of-war! 

The Problem Clearly Defined: 

President Putin comes to power at a crucial time, when the Western countries are mistakenly thinking that sufficient time has passed for the pain of colonialism to be now forgotten. Maybe, considering Zimbabwe got rid of the colonial yoke in 1980, they figure 32 years is long enough. Maybe they reckon since South Africa got rid of apartheid in 1994, sufficient time has passed. Maybe they are just desperate. I really don’t know how they calculated this, but I know they have decided that it is now time to repackage the colonialist project in the cloak of humanitarian intervention. President Mbeki quotes open discussions in Whitehall relating to renewed interest in accessing Africa’s resources by hook or crook.[3] In this new issue, Western countries actually stalk unrest in the country they will later intervene in for “humanitarian reasons.” Should the legitimate government of that country try to enforce order, this will be taken up by the Western media as the beginning of massacres and genocides that will require intervention by the “international community.” Intervention entails change of regime and the installing of a puppet regime that is friendly to the intervening countries. The puppet government’s end of the deal is to ensure access to resources and markets for the Western block in exchange for international legitimacy. How is this not colonialism? It is also quite a pathetic and transparent ploy, but does not a drowning man grasp at straws? 

President Putin reckons that the economic problems in the West today are forcing these countries to be wantonly aggressive in their search for a solution to their economic woes.[4] I believe him. Since I have already said that Russia has never been a colonial power in Southern Africa, President Putin has the moral ground to speak from. Unlike the United States which, may I remind you, had President Nelson Mandela listed as a terrorist as late as 28 June 2008.[5] 

Further Context: 

There is a palpable suspicion in academic circles that we have now entered the Third Cold War era. Relations between Russia and the West are frayed due to the United States and her proxies’ aggression in building a European Ballistic Missile Defence Shield. What this missile shield will do is take away the mutual vulnerability that has thus far ensured a stable ‘balance of terror’ between the U.S and Russia. This is the source of the major clashes between the two superpowers. Although the claim is that the shield is targeting rogue states, note that the shield will not distinguish whether missiles are from rogue states or from Russia. In any case is not a rogue state any state that the United States disagrees with at the time? The other obvious disagreements such as Russia’s position of largely respecting the building blocks of international law while the United States prefers what is expedient for the moment, are just symptoms not the disease. The bottom-line is that the United States is desperate to maintain its world hegemony against re-emerging and emerging new powers. Notice how the U.S refused to endorse the nuclear fuel exchange deal that Brazil and Turkey had brokered for Iran, not because the deal was flawed but because it had not been a U.S initiative. Observe also what has been called a policy of encircling China, military bases and diplomatic efforts placed to outmanoeuvre China on the whole globe. The hope for the U.S is to be able to dictate the law, not just to small countries but to Russia and China as well, once the United States and its proxies are invulnerable to long range missiles. President Putin has reacted to this disguised aggression by saying Russia should build a rival missile defence shield or build weapons that will ignore the missile defence shield. But I digress again, so I will not dwell much on the finer points of his solution, only to point out that he is conceiving the situation too narrowly. 

The Balance: 

In his article ostracising this disguised Western aggression; President Putin is blind to the fact that he is making the mistake of relying on the narrow solution of nuclear weapons as if Russia is still the basket case of the 90s. He is still holding on to the Russian position of being very inward looking, when a well-managed outward looking policy could win Russia useful and committed global allies without breaking her Central Bank. Russia should now start thinking in terms of exporting Russian culture, ideas, art and expertise to shore up her soft power. For instance, why should Zimbabwe recognise South Ossetia if not for the reason that her ally Russia thinks it is a legitimate thing to do? If not for the reason that Zimbabwe is obliged to stand shoulder to shoulder with her ally, Russia. 

Closely related to the above is this; the major reason why it took the West just under a month to attack Colonel Gaddafi and over 1 year to even contemplate attacking Syria despite the fact that both countries were on a similar trajectory, is because Russia has assets in Syria. These assets, should they have been damaged in a West led attack, would lead to a confrontation between Russia and the United States: game, set and match if the tennis phrase can ever be used aptly in the world of high politics. NATO furthermore cannot contemplate entering Syria because this is a contested airspace, Russian made air defence missiles induce much NATO apprehensiveness.[6] 

So, if Russia can be coaxed into looking beyond the Mediterranean, Zimbabwe is within her rights to invite military to military cooperation with Russia. Why should Zimbabwe suffer the consternation of being deprived of spares to such a backward fighter jet as the BAE Hawker Hunter when Zimbabwe could be flying Sukhoi - 35s? Why should Zimbabwe feel vulnerable to air attacks when her cities can be defended by an Air Defence Brigade wielding S – 300/400 missiles. The fact of the matter is that Russia is a leader in military technologies and many other fields, if she chooses to engage the world, countries wanting to preserve their sovereignty would do well to side with the Russia of President Putin’s vision. The West should not feel too aggrieved by this posture, the message to them would be a very friendly message; should they return to a scrupulous observation of the basic building blocks of international relations; should they return to a respect for sovereignty, honest partnerships and paying the going rate for resources, there is no reason why some limited cooperation cannot still be envisaged. 

Kudakwashe Kanhutu 
BA (Hons) Conflict, Peace & Security. University of Kent, Canterbury.
School of Politics and International Relations. 

MSc Defence, Development & Diplomacy. Durham University.
Durham Global Security Institute (DGSi). 

Prospective PhD Candidate. Graduate Institute, Geneva.
Thesis: “The State and Human Security in Zimbabwe.” 

 +447721474274 

Notes:

[1] Owing to the experiences with colonialism and apartheid, this should be a founding principle of the Charter.

[2] President Putin Being Strong: National Security Guarantees for Russia, http://rt.com/politics/official-word/strong-putin-military-russia-711/ (accessed 12/04/2012).


[3] President Mbeki Dullah Omar Eighth Memorial Lecture, http://www.unisa.ac.za/contents/colleges/docs/mbeki-speech%20at%20UWC%20(2).pdf (accessed 12/04/2012)

[4] President Putin Being Strong: National Security Guarantees for Russia, http://rt.com/politics/official-word/strong-putin-military-russia-711/ (accessed 12/04/2012).

[5] BBC, Mandela Taken Off U.S Terror List, 01 July 2008, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/7484517.stm (accessed 12/04/2012).

[6] CBS News, US General: Syrian Air Defence May Be Problem, http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-202_162-57391574/u.s-general-syrian-air-defense-may-be-problem/ (accessed 12/04/2012). Also see Senator John Mcain Interview on France 24, 12/04/12 where he says if the US cannot take out Syria’s Russian air defences then the taxpayers should question why the US government is taking their taxes.

Tuesday, 16 October 2012

“Whenever Sanctions Are Lifted, The Question Of Restitution Must Be Raised: Restitutio In Integrum, That Is”

When the heartless meet at the United Nations or, what is more often the case, declare sanctions unilaterally on other countries, this is the sort of misery they are taking out on the innocents.

Starving child struggling to reach a feeding centre in Sudan. Countries that impose sanctions on others are the real causes of such scenes. Picture by Kevin Carter.

by Kudakwashe Kanhutu

I had a dream last night that was so vivid, so real that when I woke up from it, I busied myself looking for the 3 gold medals I had won in the disciplines of swimming, archery and long distance running. In case the question has not been answered yet whether we dream in black and white or colour: I dream in colour because; the gold medals I won were gold in colour!

I do not believe I won these gold medals because I was the most outstanding athlete at the games. Instead, since I had refused to take payment for the advice I had given to the politicians of this state, I think they contrived to pay me in gold and thus let me win some disciplines. My dream however was not about my exploits at the Rome Olympics of 14 A.D. No it wasn’t. It just so happened that my invitation to advise the politicians of the day on how we moderns deal with sanctions, coincided with their Olympics year.

My dream transported me to exactly a day after the 12 year siege of Rome had been lifted. The enemies of Rome having found that they were also harming themselves economically by not doing business with Rome, chose to lift their blockade. Their attempt to choke Rome to death had not produced the full desired results. They had hoped that there would be an uprising where the people would destroy the ruling class and replace it with a puppet regime friendly to them. I arrived there to find the politicians in a heated debate on whether to now embrace the states that had caused them so much suffering by blockading Rome. One group in the debate was keen to get back to business as usual and start trading fully with the states that had blockaded them. The other side of the debate did not want to embrace, as if nothing had happened, the people who had caused the deaths of their families and ruined the Rome economy for 12 years.

The one side felt they could recover lost ground by fully going into trade. The side that was angry at having to deal with those who caused the death of their families through the blockade was beside itself with rage. The only problem is that the angry side had no proposal as to what to do next. It was to this inertia that I thought the way the moderns do things would be useful for them.

Restitutio In Integrum:

“Restitutio in integrum is a Latin maxim which means restoration to original condition. It is one of the primary guiding principles behind the awarding of damages in common law negligence claims. The general rule, as the principle implies, is that the amount of compensation awarded should put the successful plaintiff in the position he or she would have been had the tortious action not been committed. Thus the plaintiff should clearly be awarded damages for direct expenses such as medical bills and property repairs and the loss of future earnings attributable to the injury (which often involves difficult speculation about the future career and promotion prospects)." Source: Wikipedia.

Basing my advice on the above passage I read on Wikipedia only last week, I told them that their situation was very similar to the problems the moderns were having in the time before the United Nations was created. The politicians of Rome were very insightful, once I explained to them that the future is comprised of nations states and not city states as was current in their time, I didn’t have to explain anything further. I only concentrated on the issue at hand. My exact words were:

“The moderns have outlawed war and any form of aggression that is not given the go ahead (I was careful not to say "green light" since I would have been distracted into talking about the invention of the automobile etc) by the United Nations. Every nation state is now a member of this United Nations and so they meet every year to debate problems and solutions. Whenever a crisis arises, the only solution that is legal and which is beyond reproof is the one that has been signed as law and given the go ahead by the United Nations. If one country or a group of nations decide to act without the approval of the United Nations, this is called an unilateral action, nay an illegal action which must stop forthwith and the original condition restored. The United Nations has the power to impose sanctions (similar to the just ended siege of Rome) or authorize military force against an aggressor state. The point here is that if the United Nations approves of any action then it is legal. Thus if sanctions are imposed by a group of states and not the United Nations, they are illegal sanctions.”

The place I wanted to reach eventually was to talk to them about what we moderns do when what we call an Internationally Wrongful Act occurs. I quickly told them the siege they had experienced is what is now called economic sanctions in the modern age. My thoughts were that if sanctions are not imposed by the United Nations, they are an illegal act which should stop and damages paid.


Responsibility For Internationally Wrongful Acts:


Article 31

Reparation


1. The responsible State (s) is under an obligation to make full reparation for the injury caused by the internationally wrongful act.

2. Injury includes any damage, whether material or moral, caused by the internationally wrongful act of a State (s).

Source: State Responsibility for Internationally Wrongful Acts 2001. United Nations Website.[1]

I said to them therefore, suddenly inflicted by the desire to sound grave and wise: “Thus I say unto you, in my age those who feel wronged and can prove that the act was an internationally wrongful act have recourse to remedies such as the one we call Restitituo in intergrum. Which is to say, you can demand that the authors of this wrongful act which has caused you much suffering should pay you reparations and restore, as much as possible to the original condition, what your city was before they inflicted their siege on it. Where your relatives have died due to the siege, huge compensation must be paid, since the dead cannot be brought back to life. Economic losses which are calculable should be recompensed and projected incomes that were lost, paid. Those of you who insist on restitutio in integrum will be viewed as hardliners, resistant to change, and those who welcome the lifting of the siege without any further discussion will be called moderates and progressive. These names mean nothing in the long run. The main point is since you cannot impose a siege on yourselves, what you can do is to refuse to meet any conditions they have imposed on you in exchange for lifting their siege. The first thing that has to happen is that they should restore your city to its greatness before their siege began. Only then will you consider their conditions.”

There was great applause and, as with dreams, somehow we entered the Olympic Village where I proceeded to win 3 (three) gold medals in swimming, archery and long distance running. When I woke up I even looked under my bed for my gold medals, so vivid was the dream.

Sunday, 14 October 2012

Strategy For The North

“Security is development” – Robert S McNamara.

I prefer having grain silos to having nuclear silos, that's just me.

The more I find myself talking eloquently on Nuclear Strategy, the more I realise that I am being co-opted into adopting other people's problems as my own. My position - properly conceived - should be that of fearing hunger more than thermonuclear weapons.


Strategy For The North


by Kudakwashe Kanhutu


Devolution of power has been touted in Zimbabwe for a long time by the opposition and some academics. If it were to be instituted, I would hope that it follows the system they have in Nigeria as described to me when I spoke to the Rivers State’s Executive Governor - Hon. Rotimi Amaechi - in London not so long ago. I was impressed by the potential developmental positives their system holds. The problem for me is that, in Zimbabwe, devolution has not been presented primarily to realise our development goals. Development is an afterthought. The main preoccupation is diluting the power President Robert Mugabe has over central government. Some even think it possible to create a separate Ndebele State as part of this 'devolution.' The debate therefore does not get serious consideration which it could get if it was presented purely as a development agency.


Hon. Rotimi Amaechi, Rivers State Governor.


Indeed - Zimbabwe on the verge of civil war - before the Government of National Unity on 11 February 2009 offered (albeit as an extreme), the possibility of this kind of devolution, separatism if you like. In a state of war it is reasonable that people must organise themselves as best as they can for their preservation. The government will have breached the social contract in failing to deliver order and security; therefore 'devolution' becomes the logical pathway. I considered the dynamics of that eventuality and identified the area where we would make our last stand had civil war occurred. Typically I proceeded from a sentimental dimension; my family has owned land here as subsistence farmers since the Rhodesian war. The area I am from, being conterminous with Mozambique, was a very active theatre during the Liberation War. My grandparents did not leave at the height of that war, and are buried here, which too means that this is the last place for me.



I am from the northernmost tip of Zimbabwe; our landmarks are the Mavhuradonha Mountain range to the south, and the Zambezi River to the north. The mountain range forms a perfect protective wall, which cuts us off from the whole country, accessible by road only at two points. The area therefore has physical attributes suitable for defensive purposes. Its main guarantor of safety from wars of greed however, has always been that it is devoid of mineral wealth, which is also why it is currently underdeveloped, neglected and overlooked by central government. Had civil war come, it would be different from the Liberation War which was fought in the rural areas. This time the war would be in the urban areas and diamond fields, as belligerents sought to control the centre of gravity of the state. We would only need to arm and arrange ourselves as an insurance policy against defeated units coming here and causing insecurity. The main challenge in war - had it come - would have been food security, and in peace it still is food security. 

Granted, I drew my borders with defence in mind, the area that is bordered by the Mavhuradonha Mountain and the Zambezi River would have been my theatre in civil war. This was not arbitrary; this is my place in the universe. 

"Each blade of grass has its spot on earth whence it draws its life, its strength; and so is man rooted to the land from which he draws his faith together with his life."


Did I not walk barefoot to Mahuhwe and back to pick cotton seed when there was no seed at Mzarabani Growth Point? Did I not as a school child scale the Mavhuradonha Mountain to unblock leaves that had stopped our water supply on the Tank Four line? Did I not walk barefoot to church gatherings in Hoya? How about the barefoot trips to Hwata, Kapembere, Mzarabani, Sohwe and Machaya for primary schools competitions? How about when I carried sacks of fish from the Musengezi River? Swam in the Sohwe and Musengezi Rivers? Nights spent in guard huts to light fires to scare away elephants and wild pigs from our maize crop? Braved lions and leopards in defence of our livestock? Or in the dry season, did I not drive our livestock to drink from the Musengezi River?

All these places I mention are within the confines of the Mavhuradonha and Zambezi borders and they hold a special significance for me. They are populated by the people I grew up with; a functional community I owe a debt of gratitude to. You only need to consider the acts of depravity widespread in the media in some countries to understand why I feel that I grew up in the best possible community. If I can contribute so that the children growing up here today are not subject to abuses that tend to occur when extreme poverty breaks up the fabric of society. If I can make a contribution that helps restore the dignity of families here. If I can initiate a sustainable strategy for development for this community, then this debt I owe will have been repaid.

The result that comes from thinking about our community faced with the extreme danger of war, is a realisation that our community must be made resilient against whatever challenge may emerge. The constant challenge is food security, any other challenge springs from this board. As exemplified by the ability of Zimbabwean politicians to, in every election, incite normally civil neighbours to violent hatred by buying them with grain.


My desire is to help create conditions of relative prosperity that will obviate the life and death aspect of elections. If our community can feed itself, our people cannot be incited into acts of violence against each other by unscrupulous politicians in exchange for grain. I am unhappy that people who live civilly with each other throughout the year turn to murdering each other in the two weeks leading up to elections. This dynamic exists chiefly because those who live in near starvation conditions can be made to murder for their next meal. My idea is to turn the land that lies between the Mavhuradonha and the Zambezi into an oasis, disregarding that politicians would rather the whole country was a desert for the sake of power.


Her Excellency Helen Clark, former New Prime Minister and current head of the UNDP with me at a UN Forum.

To this end there are three interconnected imperatives I have always held dear: security is development, community capacity initiated by constituents and, that agriculture is the most viable development option for rural communities. These ideas were reinforced for me when I had a chat with H. E. Helen Clark, the former Prime Minister of New Zealand and current Administrator of the United Nations Development Programme. I think the first hurdle has always been people’s misconception that success in life, or development, is living in urban areas and working for a wage. The reality, however, is that (global inequities considered) in all agro-based economies such as ours, most people are better off making a living off their land. Efforts should be directed vigorously to sustaining ourselves on the land we own in the rural communities.

The primary goal for me is building capacity for self-sustenance. The requirements are quite simple but will need hard work as it will be a one man initiative to begin with. Three main things are needed, firstly, a large farm inputs depot which will make seed, pesticides, fertilisers and spares readily available in the area. The second thing required will be grain silos in the area and, thirdly, libraries to ensure that, with time, knowledge becomes easily accessible. A larger, ambitious drive would actually harness the waters of the Zambezi River for an irrigation scheme. Our proximity to the great river favours this, but that would be a longer term undertaking. The main idea is that if we succeed in agriculture and maintenance of our livestock, we will have taken a huge step in creating a key component of human security for our community. This will be the springboard for an across-the-board secure community which other rural communities can see and emulate. The big picture will be a functional country that does not depend on food aid.

Kudakwashe KANHUTU

Associations:
Durham Global Security Institute DGSI
University of Kent, School of Politics and International Relations
Royal United Services Institute for Defence and Security Studies
United Nations Association of the United Kingdom
University of London, Goldsmiths College [Classics]
[Progressive Nationalism in Zimbabwe]