Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Russia. Show all posts

Monday, 6 March 2017

Stalin: A Preliminary Post Mortem

"We think that a powerful and vigorous movement is impossible without differences — "true conformity" is possible only in the cemetery" - Josef Stalin, Pravda, "Our Purposes."

The book on Stalin

by Kudakwashe Kanhutu

One thing I must commend myself on, is my tendency to doubt everyone else’s, but my own conclusions, on all the subjects I am competent in. There are no experts but yourself when it comes to studying and applying the lessons of history to your own purposes. I need not labour this point as a lot of “experts” have been called out lately as fake news and fake historians: remember the much written about claim that Shaka, King of the Zulus, killed 2 million people during Mfecane? Never happened!

Stalin, however, is exactly as he has been described to be. Much research – including travelling to Russia itself – has made me conclude that Stalin, indeed, was the mass murderer popular culture has cast him as. But, if I had not travelled to Russia, I would not have seen, first hand, the features of Russia that redeem him. You should see the Seven Sisters of Stalin and, as well, the most beautiful underground transport system in the world – the Moscow Metro. I will be very brief as this subject will be dealt with at length in a subsequent article. For all the accusations of cruelty levelled against Stalin, he is credited with bringing Russia from being a peasant country to a Superpower in less than 20 years. The question is; could this have been achieved any other way? Do not forget that unlike the West, Russia never participated in the slave trade that is, to an extent, the foundation of Western prosperity.  

In Moscow, I was Josef Stalin, myself, walking in the same gardens at the Kremlin Stalin walked to clear his mind.
A memorial to the victims of the Gulags

A memorial to the victims of the Gulags

A memorial to the victims of the Gulags
The Moscow Metro - the best in the world.

The Moscow Metro - the best in the world.

Monday, 17 October 2016

Russia Visit: A Preliminary Post-Mortem

"All travel has its advantages. If the passenger visits better countries, he may learn to improve his own. And if fortune carries him to worse, he may learn to enjoy it" - Dr Samuel Johnson.

Russia!
by Kudakwashe Kanhutu

This is the stuff dreams are made of! My Russia visit had that magical quality one only finds in memories from childhood journeys. I have not been excited about anything - and I mean ANYTHING - for a long time, but boarding the Aeroflot Airbus A330, and sweeping into the night sky over London to head to Moscow, felt like a reward for a lifetime of efforts. And, being in Russia itself was even more reward as the whole country is a large answer book to all the philosophical, political, historical, military and international relations questions that I have wrestled with over the past 10 years. 

It will take me all of November to write everything of note with regards the trip to Russia, by which time I will probably have gone back again because I loved being in Russia. I have provisionally broken down what I will write about Russia into these four manageable sections: The People, Political History, Economic History, and Military Doctrine. These will be treatise length entries, and I make no apologies for their lengths, as subjects this important deserve such attention. These four categories are also not mutually exclusive, because the Russian psyche does not make such a distinction. Imagine if in “The People,” I choose to discuss Lenin as a historical figure of note, already in discussing him I will be touching on “Political History,” “Economic History,” and “Military Doctrine” because he wrote the book on Russia’s path in all these spheres from 1905 to present day. For Economic History, I will use my visit to the Stalingrad Tractor Plant as a case study for how communism and capitalism have been received in Russia. There are some interesting characters from Russia, one would never hear of if one does not go to Russia: Marshal Georgy Konstantinovich Zhukov is one such character. That his brilliance is not generally acknowledged in the West, while there are monuments and paintings of him on every street corner in Russia, means I will make a separate entry for him. 

My task is simple really; write all I did to visit a certain place, the things I saw and enjoyed, and the life lessons I learnt so that my reader, if he or she feels so inclined, will make the same trip and improve upon it, and in the process improve themselves. You cannot cross a time zone and fail to learn something new that will improve you.

All the technological achievements under Communism is a subject I will talk about at length.

The Motherland Calls Monument, Volgograd.

The Moscow Metro itself has museum-worthy works of art and statues.

Marshal Georgy Konstantinovich Zhukov. Adolf Hitler once said about him: "If I had one general like Zhukov, I would have achieved world domination by now."

Saturday, 7 May 2016

My Sisyphean Ordeal

“To two men living the same number of years, the world always provides the same sum of experiences. It is up to us to be conscious of them” – Albert Camus.


by Kudakwashe Kanhutu

In which I relate the exact nature of my fear that the next person may know more than me. 

The word Sisyphean refers to any interminable labour where success is never attained. Life – insofar as it always tends to end in death – is Sisyphean, but we are not going to get that philosophical in our discussion today. The Greek myth of Sisyphus holds that King Sisyphus of Corinth was punished by the gods “for his self-aggrandizing craftiness and deceitfulness by being forced to roll an immense boulder up a hill, only to watch it roll back down, repeating this action for eternity.” King Sisyphus’s deceitfulness had even begun to affect those he had never met. For example, when he was sentenced by the gods to detention in the underworld by Thanatos – the messenger of death – he tricked and chained Thanatos instead. With the messenger of death so indisposed, the result on earth was that no one would die and, with no one dying when struck, wars became difficult to win. A hue and cry was raised, and Zeus devised what can be, correctly, termed poetic justice:  “as a punishment for his trickery, King Sisyphus was made to endlessly roll a huge boulder up a steep hill. The maddening nature of the punishment was reserved for King Sisyphus due to his hubristic belief that his cleverness surpassed that of Zeus himself. Zeus accordingly displayed his own cleverness by enchanting the boulder into rolling away from King Sisyphus before he reached the top which ended up consigning Sisyphus to an eternity of useless efforts and unending frustration. Thus it came to pass that pointless or interminable activities are sometimes described as Sisyphean.” 

I have found this to be the exact nature of any determined quest for knowledge – any determined quest for anything! Forget not that just last week when I finished reading Miguel de Cervantes’s masterpiece – Don Quixote: The Ingenious Gentleman of La Mancha – I proudly announced that I had finished my quest to read all of the world’s classic works of note. Yet despite this announcement, I have just picked up Dante Alighieri’s The Divine Comedy, this, as a consequence of having recently visited Italy. But herein lies the rub, you can’t read The Divine Comedy without having first read Virgil’s The Aeneid, so I have had to put Dante aside and have to read Virgil’s Epic Poem instead. Can you picture my boulder rolling down before it reaches the top? 

My calling demands that I be conversant with all these classic works as the people I debate with, have a tendency of mentioning them in passing to illustrate a point in the debate. I was at a nuclear deterrence discussion once, when someone casually remarked that, “we run the risk, like Don Quixote, of mistaking windmills for giants, to ever be engaged with in mortal combat.” I didn’t know who the hell Don Quixote was or why he would mistake windmills for giants. I do now. I had also had to read some of these works for my Classics degree, but as will become evident below, reading to understand a work and reading to pass an exam are ever so different. A further point is that one of my hobbies is travel and, I have made reading the best classic works to come out of each country I am about to visit, part of my preparations for the visit. The more countries I visit, the more I am forced to read even more classic works. So, all these streams have met where I stand and conspired to make my quest for knowledge quite the Sisyphean ordeal. 

What you see before you now, is me having to read two more classic works in quick succession, this time from Italy. I visited Rome recently and beheld the Tiber River, walked along its banks and dipped my hand in its cool waters. This river has been a witness to history and has been invoked by poets and singers since time immemorial. It even has a nickname, they call it Flavus (The Blond). Standing before this river made me realise that I didn't know anything about this epic river. It made me remember that I had only given Virgil’s The Aeneid a very cursory read, you see, Virgil does mention and praises the Tiber River throughout his Epic Poem. I just did not know what importance the people of this land had attached to the Tiber River through the ages. 

When I read The Aeneid for my Classics exams, I only read enough to be able to build a case that Virgil’s Epic Poem closely follows the conventions set by Homer in The Iliad and The Odyssey. Such a reading does not require you to understand the story, it only needs you to pick up a few cues. Here, I will not bore you much with the details of literary study’s terms and conventions. There is something called intertextuality, whereby authors borrow from each other in telling their stories. This intertextuality is also the reason why I find myself having to properly read Virgil’s The Aeneid before I can proceed to Dante’s The Divine Comedy. My attempt to ignore The Aeneid and just read The Divine Comedy utterly failed when I opened the first page of The Divine Comedy. In the first Canto, Dante meets Virgil – and is full of praise for him – as Virgil, who died before him, becomes his guide in the underworld. There are so many references to Virgil by Dante in the first few pages that it became futile for me to try to understand The Divine Comedy without having read The Aeneid first.  

Now, I am going to Russia very soon, who knows the number of classic works from that part of the world I will be forced to read by my fear that the next person there may know more than me? In addition to all that, I must keep abreast with permutations in the contemporary world of war and diplomacy.